ABOUT
Over 20 years of experience in Sterile, Biological Pharmaceutical and Hospital Facilities Engineering Design, Construction and Validation.
Social Networks
Newsletter
Blow Thru or Draw Thru fans? - Pharmaceutical HVAC
Analysis about where to locate fans in an air handling unit: blow thru (fan before coils) and draw thru (fan after coils)
cooling, desiccant, dehumidification, excel
17986
wp-singular,post-template-default,single,single-post,postid-17986,single-format-standard,wp-theme-bridge,wp-child-theme-bridge-child,bridge-core-3.3.4.8,qode-page-transition-enabled,ajax_fade,page_not_loaded,,side_area_uncovered_from_content,hide_top_bar_on_mobile_header,qode-child-theme-ver-1.0.0,qode-theme-ver-30.8.8.9,qode-theme-bridge,disabled_footer_top,qode_header_in_grid,wpb-js-composer js-comp-ver-8.5,vc_responsive
 

Blow Thru or Draw Thru fans?

1. Introduction

 

Blow Thru or Draw Thru fans?. That’s the question I was discussing a few days ago with a colleague about the position of the fan or set of fans in an Air Handling Unit (AHU).

There are two possibilities:

  • Blow thru. The fan is located before the coils.
  • Draw thru. In this case, the fan is located after the coils.

Choosing one option or another has energy implications, so let’s try to figure out how to select the optimal arrangement.

2. Draw thru advantages

 

We know that the flow is pretty even in the negative section (suction) of the air handling unit, and less even in the discharge section (supply). That means that the face velocity through the coil will be more uniform. That is the reason why typically this is the most common arrangement.

One important thing to consider is the temperature increase due to the fan (you can see the explanation in our post Cooling and dehumidification in Excel section 3.4) so it should be considered an additional room heat gain.

3. Blow thru

 

As discussed above, this arrangement needs to add supplementary distance from the fan to the coil to achieve a uniform face velocity.

Nevertheless, there is a situation where we can use the heat generated by the fan to our benefit: in dehumidification processes. Dehumidification requires cooling and reheating, and we could save heating capacity by using the heat released by the fan.

Let’s see an example consisting of a make-up air handling unit supplying 12,800 m3/h from 32 °C / 15.14 g/Kg humidity to 18 °C / 7.20 g/Kg:

So in conclusion, by using the draw thru arrangement, in this particular case, we can get substantial energy savings. Ask your favourite engineering office for analysis in order to figure out the possible benefits of one arrangement or another.

Blow thru or Draw thru fans? The answer is: it depends!

2 Comments
  • Xavier Valls
    Posted at 11:16h, 13 June Reply

    Hola, recientemente nos hemos encontrado con la configuración de ventilador antes de las baterías lo siguiente:
    Climatización para sala limpia, por lo que el funcionamiento es ininterrumpido.
    Después de las baterías se encuentran los filtros eficacia F-9.
    El caudal del equipo es de 30.000 m3/h.
    El aire después de la batería de agua fría normalmente se acerca a la saturación (100% de humedad relativa).
    Al estar trabajando ininterrumpidamente, los filtros se han mojado, incluso hemos detectado la aparición de moho.
    La sala no se ha visto afectada porque los filtros finales H-14 estaban perfectos.

    Si el ventilador se encuentra después de las baterías, el calor generado por este es suficiente para incrementar la temperatura un par de grados, disminuyendo la HR.
    Esta muy resumido, pero espero se entienda.
    Saludos.

    • Manel Fernandez
      Posted at 11:28h, 13 June Reply

      Hola Xavier, gracias por tu comentario. Varios temas a considerar aquí. En la medida de lo posible hay que evitar trabajar con humedades próximas a la saturación, a menos que se trate de un pretratamiento del aire, alejado de la unidad de recirculación de aire, que es la más crítica. Asumo que hay instalado un separador de gotas. La velocidad de paso de aire a través de la batería es un factor determinante para evitar el arrastre de gotas de agua. Por último, es recomendable respetar un espacio mínimo entre baterías y filtros. En resumen, ¡todo un reto el mejorar esta instalación!
      Saludos

Post A Comment